My depression and what I did to end it

August 13, 2017: My theories on this subject have changed. Until I can get my act together to update this content, please see this post.

The text below was last updated February 6, 2012.

My depression lasted from junior high until I was about 31. I realized by ninth grade that it was not event- or environment-based. At around 30, after 18 months on antidepressants, I realized they were a disaster for me and I looked elsewhere for solutions. A few months later, and after two years of unemployment due to my mental state, I found success with a gluten-free diet. At first I thought that all my problems had been solved, and it truly was the end of my despair, but if I had to go back to my mood in those early “I’m cured!” days, it would terrify me. But at the time, it was so much better than my norm that it was a miracle.

It took about two more years of tinkering with my diet and supplements before I realized I was normal. And with no help from any doctor, thank you very much, although they occasionally were of use on other issues. Just a lot of internet searching and a few alternative health books.

Following the logic that since celiac disease (for which a gluten-free diet is the solution) results in malabsorption and thus nutritional deficiencies, that my health problems were caused by nutritional deficiencies, I went in that direction, and with a few exceptions stayed on that road.

Here’s a list of the supplements/treatments/practices that definitely had an effect on my depression, which is about one-tenth of what I actually tried. Mind you, I never took ALL of these at the same time, and only take a few of them now, on occasion.

  • Quit gluten.

  • Quit dairy. Resumed when corrected zinc deficiency.

  • Calcium/magnesium: 1000/500 per day at first? Maybe more.

  • Zinc: 50 mg/day for about a year, then cut back. This had the most noticeable effect of all the supplements. After a few months on it, I could eat dairy again without it lowering my mood. (The casein in dairy binds with zinc.)

  • Iron: Varying amounts.

  • B-complex: Started with B-50 3x/day.

  • Plus more of the following B vitamins, which B-complex doesn’t have enough of, as they are too expensive for the manufacturer. Compare the various RDA percentages on the B-complex label to get an idea of the different amounts.
    — Biotin: 1-2,000 mcg
    — Folic acid: 400-800 mcg. See note below about newer, better form.
    — B12: 1-2,000 mcg. ” “

  • Vitamin D3: 2,000 IU/day. Helped mood a bit, but mostly sleep. I should’ve tried a lot more but at the time the “experts” said that amount was pushing it.

  • Omega-3 EFAs. I took a lot of these for several years.

  • Treated for hypothyroidism. Zinc helped this, as did low-goitrogen diet, Armour thyroid for 18 months, and acupuncture, which I tried after I got tired of being slave to a prescription. After about 15 treatments in nine weeks with an M.D./D.O.M., I was able to stop the Rx.

  • Light therapy in winter for 30 minutes in morning. For me it prevents plummeting mood, insane carb cravings, zombie brain, and near-total insomnia.

Still affecting my mood:

  • Winter (seasonal affective disorder / SAD): I am assuming that lots of vitamin D3 will eventually fix this, but I developed a reaction to vitamin D3 supplements and can’t get my levels high enough. Ideal results for the 25(OH)D test are supposedly 50-80 nmol/L, but I can’t get above 20 nmol/L. Also, I have noticed that the light therapy doesn’t work if I do it after 8 a.m., whereas for the first several years it worked as long as I did it by 9 a.m.

  • Vicodin. (Demerol, however, is lovely.)

  • If I take a whole lot of something that competes with zinc and/or B vitamins — for example, my recent experiments with huge doses of Ca/Mg for energy — I’ll have to take those supplements to keep my mood from falling.

  • Not getting enough calories. I’ll feel it two days later.

  • Assholes.

Notes:

I did not know until this year about the limitations of folic acid and B12 cobalamin/cyanocobalamin supplements (as opposed to methylfolate and methylcobalamin). I wonder if using those better supplements would have sped up my progress.

I’ve never taken a whole lot of things at once, as it makes it difficult to figure out what the heck is doing what, I find it overwhelming and annoying, and I just can’t digest all that much.

I still experiment a great deal with supplements, but not for the depression end of things. Knock on wood.

3 thoughts on “My depression and what I did to end it

  1. Ross

    Thanks for that,
    I have done many of the things you have tried with varying degrees of success, they all helped a little. Certainly the B12 and folic acid vs Methylcobalamin and MTHF are factors. I have not found that the methylcobalamin and MTHF have greatly helped, but I have found that Cyano and folic acid impede progress. I found that cyanocobalamin actually causes depression for me and once I isolated it from the multivitamins and took cyano on its own I noticed a depressive mood almost immediately on taking it.(30 minutes).
    Unfortunately I did not find the opposite effect from Methylcobalamin, but if you are taking B12, then methylcobalamin is the only choice in my opinion. I have heard of many people noticing positive changes taking MTHF especially those with the common gene mutation that prevents conversion of folic acid (a synthetic version of folate).
    The biggest thing for me was probiotics. The effect on my two year depression was almost immediate (18 hours). I have found though that not all probiotics are created equal, but if you want to fix depression for good that is where I would look. I also believe that almost all depression is “caused” by antibiotics (multiple doses) and the other sources of bacteria killing chemicals eg chlorine, fluoride, antibacterial soaps and toothpastes. This theory is strongly supported by studies and also mainstream psychiatry which is heavily supported by the serotonin theory of depression. I believe the serotonin theory of depression is mostly correct, and serotonin is mostly created in the gut by gut bacteria. This is also the basis for the GAPS diet which has been very successful in treating psychiatric illness. I have not followed the GAPS diet myself but I believe in its efficacy, and probiotics are a big part of that.
    Another thing that has helped with my sleep and mood (this will almost sound silly) is wearing yellow glasses at night. The glasses cost about $10. I wear them from about 8pm onwards and dont expose myself to any light after 8pm without the glasses. I sleep well and wake up refreshed. You can look it up on the net, it actually works and I have recommended this to others, it helps those that need it.

    Reply
    1. Marjorie Post author

      Your experience with probiotics is very interesting. I have also tried to focus on the larger picture of what causes depression and my experience over the past two years has been on inflammation — in my case caused by mold poisoning; years of a diet heavy in wheat (like all Americans), which is naturally inflammatory; and Roundup in the food supply. Most of the things that helped my depression, even Zoloft, turned out to be anti-inflammatory. (I think that’s why I reacted to it in 24 hours.)

      Mold patients are also interested in probiotics because mold toxins destroy the gut biome even as you detox. However, in my case, probiotic supplements stop me sleeping, and some worry that the strains in supplements are too limited. Some people resort to making their own fermented foods — kimchi, etc. — to avoid pasteurization, but I do not have that kind of devotion.

      BTW my understanding is that the medical community has moved away from the neurotransmitter model of depression, as it did not seem to explain the majority of cases. However, doctors continue to explain it that way to their patients.

      I also use the blue-blocking or dimming function on my e-readers at night. Definitely helps me get to sleep.

  2. Viaaaagra

    This is spam, but it made me laugh:

    the next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I actually thought youd have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could fix if you werent too busy looking for attention.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *